High reps – Low weight vs High weight – Low reps for building muscle
Updated: Aug 3, 2022
The ACSM (2011) states that robust gains in both hypertrophy and strength occur at 60-80% of an individuals 1RM
– The NSCA (2008) recommends 67-85% 1RM for muscular hypertrophy
– Burd et al. (2010) found that performing exercise at 30% 1RM and 90% 1RM resulted in similar levels of muscle protein synthesis and anabolic signalling
– Mitchell et al. (2012) found that performing a leg extension at 30% 1RM and 80% 1RM resulted in a similar increase in muscle size over a 10 week period. However, the 80% 1RM group experienced a greater increase in strength
– Ogasawara (2013) found that performing bench press at 30% 1RM and 80% 1RM resulted in equivalent increases in muscular hypertrophy but again, the 80% 1RM group experienced greater strength increases
– Schoenfeld et al. (2015) demonstrated that resistance training at 25-35% 1RM was as effective as performing 8-12 reps to failure for increasing muscle size but the 8-12 group experienced greater increases in their Squat strength
Henneman’s size principle (1965) stated that recruitment of High-threshold motor units is dependent on the intensity of the stimulus. I.e. more motor units will be recruited at a higher %1RM than a lower one (80% vs 30%)
However performing submaximal contractions (30% 1RM) to full fatigue may result in the recruitment of additional higher threshold motor units.
Along with this Burd et al. stated that performing sets at a lower intensity (around 30% 1RM) to full volitional fatigue could achieve similar levels of muscle fiber activation as that of a higher intensity (around 80%) set.
Mitchell et al. hypothesised that maximal motor unit recruitment was required for sustained force production when performing low load sets (approx 30%) to failure.
Nathaniel et al. (2015) performed a more in depth analysis when comparing 30% 1RM to 80% 1RM. They measured EMG amplitude, EMG mean power frequency, exercise volume, total work and muscle activation, and time under concentric load, as well as changes in muscle cross-sectional area before and after 3 sets to failure at the 2 intensity levels.
Their results:
– Higher EMG amplitude at 80%
– Lower EMG mean power frequency at 30%
– Greater increase in muscle cross-sectional area in 30%
– Higher volume, total work, and time under concentric load for 30%
From this we can gather that muscle activation is greater at 80%
It should be noted as well that throughout these studies volume was not equated – If it was I theorise that the higher %RM group would’ve experienced a higher increase in muscle growth. As well as this a reason for the increased cross-sectional area of the muscle during the 30% trials may have been the swelling of the muscle aka the pump that you get from performing lots of reps.
Removing these factors though, even if the muscular hypertrophy effects are equal from the 30% and 80% trials, in all cases the 80% group had greater increases in strength. The basic rule of building muscle is that you must achieve progressive overload overtime. The easiest way to achieve progressive overload overtime is by increasing the amount of weight you lift overtime. This will then assist in increasing your training volume of ever rep range and intensity level thus leading to a greater increase in muscle mass
Author – Jayden (Coach) Damrow


Comments